 |
Michael_Novakhov shared this story from  The Jewish Voice.
|
(TJV NEWS) Pressure is intensifying on Shin Bet Director Ronen Bar as Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and key government officials move to oust him following deepening allegations of negligence and political misuse of his office. At the heart of the storm are the devastating failures that led to the October 7 Hamas invasion and the unfolding “Qatargate” scandal involving foreign money and influence in Israel’s political sphere.
Netanyahu’s spokesperson Omer Dostri previously accused Bar of failing to act on critical intelligence that could have prevented the massacre. “Ronen Bar had the opportunity to retire with honor after his searing failure on October 7, as the outgoing Chief of Staff did,” Dostri said. “But he preferred not to attend the government meeting dealing with his case simply because he was afraid of giving answers.”
“Why, after you knew about the Hamas attack many hours before it happened, did you do nothing and not call the Prime Minister – something that would have prevented the disaster?” Dostri added.
The Prime Minister himself has reportedly lost all confidence in Bar, who remains in office despite calls for his dismissal from bereaved families, security officials, and senior lawmakers.
The government has filed a petition with the High Court to lift a temporary order blocking Bar’s removal, arguing that continued immunity for the Shin Bet head undermines Israel’s democratic structure and civilian control over security institutions.
“A period of immunity for the head of the service, during which the clear directive of the legislator is suspended, severely harms the realization of the goals of the Shin Bet,” said a statement from the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO), as reported by <a href=”http://AllIsrael.com” rel=”nofollow”>AllIsrael.com</a>.
October 7: A Catastrophic Security Breakdown
The failure of Israel’s domestic intelligence agency to anticipate or thwart the October 7 attack is now central to calls for Bar’s resignation. Families of soldiers killed in the war say accountability must start at the top.
In a raw and emotional interview with 103FM, Tzik Bonzel, father of Sgt. Amit Bonzel who was killed in Gaza, spoke out after a face-to-face meeting with Bar:
“Had he lived up to his responsibilities and dealt with things properly, today Amit would be alive—and with him, hundreds, if not thousands, of Israelis.”
Bonzel described the encounter as deeply painful and said Bar appeared unprepared for the intensity of the criticism. “I demanded to know when he would resign and stop harming this holy organization,” Bonzel said.
“Qatargate” and Political Weaponization
Fueling the storm is the so-called “Qatargate” affair, in which Shin Bet allegedly uncovered that advisers to Netanyahu received funds from Qatar, a nation widely known for financing Hamas. Critics claim the prime minister is attempting to silence Bar to derail the investigation.
Left-leaning NGOs, including the Movement for Quality Government (MQG), have accused Netanyahu of politicizing the ISA and attacking law enforcement institutions. But the Prime Minister’s allies argue that Bar has weaponized his position, using the hostage crisis and sensitive information to shield himself from criticism.
“The Israeli government, which is in charge of the Shin Bet, has lost all confidence in Ronen Bar, who continues to cling to his seat while cynically using the families of the kidnapped,” said Dostri, according to The Jerusalem Post.
Netanyahu’s Approach: Soft Pressure, Hard Questions
Though Netanyahu has largely refrained from personal attacks, his decision to invite Bar to join a security briefing this week was widely seen as a final olive branch amid rising tensions. That same day, the government formally requested the High Court lift its hold on Bar’s dismissal.
“If Ronen Bar had carried out his role as he is currently clinging to his seat, we would not have reached October 7,” Dostri concluded.
For many Israelis, the question is no longer whether Ronen Bar should go—but why he hasn’t already. As <a href=”http://AllIsrael.com” rel=”nofollow”>AllIsrael.com</a> notes, the ongoing court wrangling and political defense of Bar are delaying overdue accountability at a time when public trust in the Shin Bet—and the entire security establishment—is at historic lows.
In the eyes of Netanyahu, grieving families, and a growing number of lawmakers, Ronen Bar’s continued leadership is incompatible with national recovery, operational reform, and trust in Israel’s most vital security institutions. The question is whether Israel’s legal system will let the government act—or let this crisis fester furthe
